Volume 12, Number 10
22 November 2005





Click, to go back to the contents of this issue

This Week



We appreciate feedback from our readers
Browse through the collecton of older issues



"LIFE ETC."

Pity: A Source of Exclusion

While watching the shocking scenes shot in the Malatya Orphanage, I asked myself what kind of a human being could treat a little kid like that. Let me leave this question here; I'll get back to it in the end.

Generally, when I get too bored at home, I start a discussion from out of nowhere. Dad, just like millions of other family men, is a great
target for such provocations because of his adoption of the norms of society, the common sense of the majority, and tradition. One evening, I decided to get some action. I started to ask questions about the never-questioned negative estimation of retirement homes for the aged. The discussion came to a point where my parents used their ultimate weapon: "OK, if you like the idea that much, you can send us to a rest home when we get old." Case closed.

Yes, the case was closed, but since that day, I've continued to feel like a conventional Hollywood detective who just can't help reopening closed cases. I still ask why a person has to take care of his/her parents if there are good retirement homes with an atmosphere more suitable for old people. Why would a bedridden elderly man or woman find it degrading to live in a good rest home with a trained staff if he/she doesn't work and all he/she has to do is get up, eat, breathe, etc.?

It's interesting, but we don't need a huge investigation to tell us that the vast majority of our society finds it "abnormal" to live in a rest home. People never perceive the inhabitants of such homes as "normal people who need professional help because of their age and illnesses."

Consciously or not, the same judgment--that those who need it are "abnormal"-is made regarding many other kinds of professional help. According to society, an orphanage is not a place where normal children get professional help because their parents are not around to bring them up; it's a place where "abnormal" children are kept together. They never perceive a psychologist as a person who gives professional help to normal people when they need it; according to them, a person has to be crazy if he/she's talking to a shrink.

People pity psychologists' patients. They also pity the residents of rest homes, orphanages, hospitals and so on. Their pity makes them perceive those "miserable" people as "different," this differentiation feeds exclusion, and exclusion creates a gap between the standard of living society demands for itself and for "the excluded." Once someone excludes another person, he/she no longer perceives that person as a human being who deserves respect.

So, would it be wrong to claim that pity might wipe out respect? What if the only thing the children in Malatya Orphanage need is respect instead of pity? And what if the media have been channeling our feelings in the wrong direction?


 

İsmail O. Postalcıoğlu (POLS/III)
ismail_orhan@yahoo.com

 Click, to go back to the contents of this issue








Bilkent News Welcomes Feedback From Readers.
This newsletter will print letters received from readers.
Please submit your letters to bilnews@bilkent.edu.tr
or to the Communications Unit, Engineering Building, room EG-23, ext. 1487.
The Editorial Board will review the letters and print according to available space.